
Erica G.
I want you to get your best friend and ask her to read this letter to you. Imagine that she is the one who is dealing with this problem. What advice would you give her? It is obvious that he is using you, and your attitude is just an excuse for him to get out of this relationship. You need to reassess your definition of love. When a person loves you, they show it through respectful, caring, giving actions and emotionally supportive words. You need to confront the fact that he has cheated on you repeatedly and ask yourself if you truly believe that is love. I understand that you have feelings for this man, but that doesn't mean you should allow yourself to be disrespected and mistreated. Dump this guy, and take the time to figure out the definition of love and how you should be treated by someone who really loves you.
I have a question about a relationship that I may or may not be in. We have known each other for years and we broke up because he was not ready to commit at the time. We went our separate ways and years later we saw each other again and a lot had changed. He told me how much he wanted to be with me, but after a few disagreements about the same issues he started ignoring me. We are both Scorpios and are very strong willed and he says he is ignoring me because he does not want to argue. I am trying to step back and take it slow. We have history and I am in love with him, but he is not paying any attention to me now. I always make the first move and call him everyday. Every time I try to talk to him about this he tells me I'm starting an argument. I think he has another woman, because we haven't been sleeping together that much. Should I give up or is this his way of punishing me for things I've said and how I've acted?
A.J.
It sounds like you both re-entered into this relationship with the idea that things had changed, and that all your issues had miraculously worked themselves out. Once the initial newness wore off, you found the same old problems were there and you were both still ill-equipped to handle them. You can't address this problem with the same tools you used before. They didn't work then, and they are now causing you both to repeat the past. Arguments are just two people with conflicting views in a power struggle to gain the upper ground. When you both believe you are right, and are unwilling to see the world through your partners eyes, then the connection between you is severed. His response to the power struggle is to shut down and retreat to his cave. He is shutting you out because he doesn't know any other way. As he retreats, you push harder which makes him shut down more. Ask him if he is still invested in this relationship and if he is willing to do whatever it takes to make it work. If this relationship is something that you are both serious about pursuing then you need to take a class in couples connection, communication, and crossing the bridge (HedyYumi.org).
Rebecca Brody is a Relationship Coach in New York City. She is the creator of She Caught the Crazy! If you need relationship advice or want to work with Coach Brody contact Brody@TheLuvCoach.com or go to www.TheLuvCoach.com. For more crazy stories visit www.SheCaughtTheCrazy.com


Comments: (28)
Add a comment
By: R hayes on 4/07/2010 9:16AM
these two letters sound like women efforting so much with two "men" who are obviously not putting your needs or feelings first. you love to love, that's what your feeling, not that you love them. and wow, irregular sex... when they need... wow... ladies, queens, epitome... that's you, not the "on the knees" scrap hunting weaklings they are playing you for. Self-check and self reliance first. I know there are few real men out there... probably exactly the same amount of real women too which means there's just enough.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: kathryn on 4/07/2010 10:17AM
Sorry - it sounds like two women who are stupid.
Report This
By: lois masterson on 4/07/2010 10:45AM
When the government provides the $$$$$$$$$$$ for the unmarried mothers the mindset is swayed to not have the responisbility of even caring for your own child as this selfish father is doing.........but then take a look at Tiger as whatever feels good for ME is Ok...............Sad world for the coming generation...........
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: You live in a fantasy world women on 4/07/2010 4:13PM
Women are the most promiscous and demonized unstable creatures in world. When women dont like something that they create and live like nothing is thier fault they make the man look bad and take advantage. They cry wolf of poor little woman, "Oh poor me Im a woman why is he doing this to me", when in fact they live in a fantasy world. One good prospect of this is SOAP operas, look how long they have been running these fantasies on tv and BECAUSE OF WOMEN. Ignorance is not bliss women so move on. Quit running around blind and take a look at this ugly world you have created!
Report This
By: dvine on 4/08/2010 3:52PM
@ You live in a fantasy world women - and what are men? men cheat, lie and steal. pass along std's and walk out on their children, their wives, their fiances, their girlfriends and their pregnant spouses. ur comment was hilarious. while u may describe the women you have encountered - all women do not behave in this manner. for you to blame women completely is stupid on your behalf. Hell did u read the post about Tiki Barber.. Left his pregnant wife for a younger woman.!! now come again..
Report This
By: Anita on 4/07/2010 10:37AM
The men are treating these women EXACTLY the way the women allow them to. WAKE UP girls
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Angiebaby on 4/07/2010 10:50AM
Dear Erica G.,
Let me see if I can sum up your letter in just a few sentences. You and this heathen went out a few times, but before the 6th month mark, he stopped sleeping with you because his REAL girlfriend was pregnant and his other ho' was taking up his free time. You kept calling him and he would drop by for a booty call, a dollar bill or a set of wheels once in a while. Essentially, everything he wanted FROM you, but not WITH you. You gave this man everything, and he gave you heartache, bills and guilt trip for his meanness.
Now, if you haven't gotten the picture from my first paragraph, let me make your situation just a little clearer. Are you being blind? Yes, and deaf & dumb while you're at it! Listen, sweetie, if there is one thing a single, 24-year-old man will make time for it's a girlfriend he really likes. (Don't we ALL make time for what's important to us?) So, you see, it's not that he can't make time for you; he can, but he won't. And he sure as hell ain't going to take you out. Why not? He doesn't want anything to do with you, and besides, taking you out costs money.
I don't know what AdviceMommyDearest is thinking, but she is wrong to tell you the guy is making excuses to get out of a relationship with you, and that you should dump him. Erica G., this double-dealing rascal isn't IN a relationship with you, and you can't dump somebody you aren't in a relationship with. But AdviceGuru thinks you can. So I really want to know...HOW CAN YOU DUMP SOMEBODY WHO SHUNS YOU LIKE A LEPER, ADVICEMAMA?
Erica G., the man does not love you, never did. He didn't get his ex pregnant while he was with you, he was seeing you behind his pregnant girlfriend's back. After a few hook ups, he stopped bothering with you at all, unless he wanted cash & transportation. Sister, you need to close that bank, get out of the car leasing business, and close the pootie factory while you Exorcise this wastrel from your life. Reality hurts sometimes, but be thankful you learned this lesson early in life because someday, when real love comes along, you will know what it is. Sometimes to know what something is, you have to first know what it is not.
Signed,
I didn't want to say it, but I suspect you're obsessed, bordering on stalker material.
Now, on to you, Ms. A.J. Hmmm. Seems you were in a relationship that was not healthy for you or your sugar biscuit. The two of you went your separate ways, ran into each other again, and he told you he really wanted to be with you. But things aren't any better than before. Am I right?
Okay. Well, somebody's gotta' say it, so listen carefully, A.J., because this is what I think happened. You two bumped into each other at the club, had a few drinks, and after you told him how great he looked, how much you missed him and flirted you ass off, a little light bulb began pulsating in his head. His little one. So he said I want to be with you, but WHAT THE REPROBATE MEANT was I want to be with you naked tonight. And while you were happy hear his drunken declaration, WHAT YOU THOUGHT HE MEANT was he wanted to get back with you, work things out, get married, have 2.3 children and live happily ever after.
In this case, I will give AdviceMama a little credit. But just a tee-ninecy bit. (That's southern for "negligible amount") You DO need some new tools to work this out. Specifically, a chastity belt and a thinking cap! And to answer your first dilemma, you, my friend, are NOT in a relationship. Not outside of your head and your bed, anyway. This scapegrace isn't shutting you OUT, because you ain't IN. And I'm not sure what AM was thinking when she said you two need to take a class in couples connection, communication, and crossing the bridge. I nearly fell out of my chair when I read that one! I mean, the unscrupulous weasel isn't connected, won't communicate and has thrown you under the bridge. I'm just not thinking he's going to go to counseling with you. If you can't figure out the guy used you for a booty call, let me help you out. Hooking up at a club and having zero contact with you except to let you chase him and drop your drawers for him is not only a booty call, but it's the kind men dream about! The girl calls him to come 'n get it, if you get my meaning. Hell, he doesn't even have to push 7 little buttons on the damn phone to get it.
The truth is, you are focusing on the idea of you two as a couple, and it's wrong thinking. You need to let go, and move on, however hard that may be. You cannot make him love you, and being with him the way he is would ultimately make you hate yourself. Think this through... what if he DID love you? You'd be stuck with a self-centered, disrespectful, emotionally abusive man who would most likely be running around on you. Don't you want better? Don't you deserve better?
Signed,
You'd have gotten better advice from Aksing Ike than you got from this b*tch!
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: WTF? on 4/07/2010 11:06AM
Angiebaby, you are wise beyond your years, well written and should write your own advise column. You are spot on,,,good job.
Report This
By: MeritaBread on 4/07/2010 2:48PM
Angiebaby, this was hilarious, but spot-on! If the two young women will HEAR you, they will be so much better off. The first one for sure was used shamelessly, but she set herself up for it and is still begging for more. The second one is fooling herself into believing she can make a square peg fit into a round hole. I don't even hold the guy to blame in that one. The relationship didn't work before. It's not working now. He is trying to let her down kindly, but she is so desperate that she is holding on for dear life. I agree with the previous commenter: get your own advice column. Sometimes the hard truth, the way you just put it out there, is just what those in the throes of love/lust/obsession need to hear, not some politically correct sugar pill that does no one any good. Keep on keeping it real.
Report This
By: chekara on 4/07/2010 2:57PM
I NEED UR ADVICE PLZ REPLY BACK TO ME I WROTE MY PROBLEM ON HERE AND NO ONE REPLIED BACK TO IT AND YOU SEEM LIKE YOU WOULD HELP ME OUT ALOT.
Report This